Anime Quick Information

Title: .hack// Roots #1
UK publisher: Beez
Genre: Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi
Studio: Bee Train
Type: TV Series
Director: Koichi Mashimo
Year: 2006
Running Time: 1 hr 40 mns
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 8.16

Sarah's review

Sarah scored this with 6/10. Disagree?

The World R:2 is a newer and improved version of the MMORPG featured in the TV anime series ‘.hack//sign’ which was notable for its wonderful score by Yuki Kajiura. New series ‘.hack//roots’ plunges us straight into The World R:2 with new player Haseo. The score by Mikiya Katakura is a wild and whacky eclectic fusion of bits of everything from the Queen of the Night’s coloratura aria (Mozart’s ‘Magic Flute’), Scott Joplin-style piano ragtime, Celtic fringe, and contemporary electronic techniques, all cleverly mixed by the inventive ALI Project (who play real instruments!). The opening song ‘Silly-Go-Round’ is by Yuki Kajiura and the aptly bizarre yet catchy final song ‘Boukoku Kakusei Catharsis’ is just as good, capturing the weirdness of Haseo’s experiences in The World.

I could wish, however, that the storyline was as anyway near inventive or involving as the score. Haseo starts his time in The World by being killed by a PK (Player Killer). Revived and rescued by the enigmatic Ovan, he is told that he has ‘a gift’ and is ‘special’. Phyllo, an observer, takes an interest in the confused Haseo and gives him helpful advice. Phyllo also serves to remind us that we are also merely observers in an RPG (no-one here is really what they seem) when he suddenly fades out and then in again when his cat pulls out the cord of his computer. Haseo meets Shino, a sweet-natured ally of Ovan’s, who tries to persuade him to join Ovan’s guild, the Twilight Brigade, in their search for the mysterious Key of Twilight. Shino has been looking after Tabby, another newbie, a cute and lively catgirl; the fourth current member is Sakisaka.

Another guild, TaN, run by the panther-faced Naobi, is after the Twilight Key. After rumours about Haseo’s unique qualities are spread on the forum (reputedly by Ovan?) two of their number, the sexy Player Killer Ender and the lumbering treasurer Narawaya, set out to try to persuade Haseo to join them. Haseo, inexperienced in the ways of The World, suddenly finds himself the centre of unwanted attention.

I wish there were some other way to put it, but ‘.hack//ROOTS’ is slow. Very slow. Maybe if you play the related games, it becomes more meaningful, but to me, an animated TV series has to work first and foremost as an unfolding drama on its own terms. There’s way too much dialogue of the "So; what d’you think we should do now?" Pregnant pause. "Who knows...?" variety.

As in the original series, the viewer is left wondering how much the characters’ online personalities reflect their offline identities in the ‘real’ world – and to what extent these dynamics will affect the outcome of their player lives in The World. And vice versa! At the end of Episode 2, for example, the camera pans slowly away from Shino sitting admiring a beautiful landscape with a cute digital deer creature sitting beside her. It’s all very pretty. But at the end of an anime episode, I want to be left desperate to know what’s coming next. Or even a little curious. If it weren’t for the quirkiness of the final song, coupled with the visual hints at what Haseo’s ‘gift’ might be, it would be way too easy to walk away from the series and not return.

Visually, ‘.hack//Roots’ is pleasing to watch; the attractive character designs recall those of the first series, although the graphics are much more sophisticated (seven years have passed, after all!).

The box set for Volume 1 also contains the first of two original soundtrack CDs, a really dinky light-up key-ring and a helpful booklet with character guides and explanations of the terms used in The World. As the soundtrack is, in my opinion, the best thing going for ‘hack//Roots’, this makes an attractive package.

In Summary

A brilliantly inventive soundtrack – but will that alone be enough to sustain interest in this slow return to The World? This viewer, for one, was desperate for way more action and more plot development. Perhaps that will come in Volume 2…

Screenshots (click to pop out)

Review Information

Score: 6 out of 10
Review By: Sarah
Date Published: Sat, 1 Dec 2007
2 responses to our review of ".hack// Roots #1"

1. Comment by Trumpster

A agree with a lot of what you said, and have to give a similar rating, though boosted due to my enjoyment of the MMORPG references, which seem more common in //roots than //sign.

The first disk is very slow and I had to think hard about whether I'd continue the series but it didn't take long of rewatching .Hack//Sign to remind me why it was going to be a good anime.

Honestly, at this point I'd say it was only worthwhile for fans, but the collectors box sets are certainly a good incentive this time round, god knows I was annoyed just after I finished collecting .Hack//Sign to be shown a couple of box sets with limited extras. ¬.¬

I'd agree with the first disk being a cautious investment and until the story progresses you can't be sure whether the finale is going to be in the same league as the previous series.

Posted on Sun, 2 Dec 2007. Trumpster rated ".hack// Roots #1": 7 out of 10.

2. Comment by Wildcard

Had me intrigued, but the pacing really is slow (at least in this volume) and I soon began to get a bit impatient. I can't say how much better it gets later on but it certainly takes a while to get moving.

Still, the soundtrack is pretty decent so the boxset isn't so bad.

Posted on Tue, 4 Dec 2007. Wildcard rated ".hack// Roots #1": 5 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of ".hack// Roots #1"

Editorial Spotlight

In the last volume reporter-hopeful Tozawa discovered Masane's secret, and forced her into a partnership, aiding his research into the X-con and Cloneblade (Neogene) murders.. Read more (0 comments)
Lupin III is one of the longest running anime franchises in Japan. Spanning over forty years with three TV series, yearly television specials and a series of feature films with.. Read more
Reviewing Ergo Proxy has actually been a pleasure, and, in the same sense, I imagine that most people making the informed decision of buying into the series are inevitably going.. Read more (1 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

jeremy on Ergo Proxy #6

Well put! took the words from my mind and cleaned them up to make sense. i would call it a beautifully flawed series, if anything (Read more)

poppyman on Najica Blitz Tactics

Totally agree with your review,I think you could do a lot worse than spend a relaxing evening with Najica. (Read more)

Nemorivarex on Otogi Zoshi #6

I really love Mansairaku, although he wasn't with his lover Hikaru after all. Although his duty for his homeland was fulfilled but what about his... (Read more)

Taki on Black Lagoon #2

Great review. I am loving the Black Lagoon series so far. The first 3 episodes of Black Lagoon - Second Barrage are good enough to form their own... (Read more)

Travis on Elemental Gelade #2

i dont care about enthing about that i saw all 26 episodes and now im rly exited for the enxt series of elemental gelade believed to be comign this... (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.