Anime Quick Information

Title: Ergo Proxy #1
UK publisher: MVM Films
Genre: Sci-Fi, Thriller
Studio: Manglobe INC
Type: TV Series
Director: Shukou Murase
Year: 2005
Running Time: 1hrs 40mins
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 8.34

Ryan's review

Ryan scored this with 8/10. Disagree?

Ergo Proxy appears, from first impressions, to be a uniquely thoughtful and reflective series, conceived within the framework of a Westernised vision of a conversely utopian and dystopian society.

The story begins in the city of Romdo, a domed structure that established wisdom regards as a paradise, and a defence against the uninhabitable outside world. Equally, it is also a society founded on the repression of information and one's own feelings, bearing the hallmarks of Orwellian surveillance and Draconian punishment. Autoreivs, or robots, also exert a significant presence within Romdo, aiding affluent members of society and professionals, whilst monitoring and spying upon them.

Re-l Mayer, an elite agent in the employ of the Intelligence Bureau and the protagonist, is assigned to investigate the spreading Cogito virus, which is believed to produce self-awareness and emotion within the Autoreivs - things that need to be suppressed, and are discouraged even among citizens. Upon examination of the immigration districts with her own Autoreiv assistant, Iggy, which have been the home of recent Cogito infected attacks, Re-L soon comes into contact with the real culprit - a creature far more dangerous than the infected Autoreivs - a monstrous being known as a Proxy.

After returning home, Re-l tries to continue about her life, but is again disturbed by the Proxy, which crashes through her roof, and engages another in a fight that destroys much of her residence. Made to follow procedure, Re-l is tried with identifying her "attacker" from a database of citizens in Romdo, but is naturally unable, and becomes frustrated upon discovering that acknowledgement of the Proxy has been withheld, and Iggy's memories erased.

Meanwhile, a number of powerful members of society, from the doctor Deadalus, to Raul, the Director-General of the Citizen Security Bureau, and the immigrant Vincent Law, are found themselves to be intrigued by, and in varying degrees embroiled in the mystery of the Proxies. Against this backdrop, Re-l dangerously continues her search for the Proxy, while Vincent tries to escape the false-accusations of the Romdo government - who pin him as the culprit and a scapegoat.

The story is intricate and well-paced, with a variety of surprises which I have tried to avoid divulging by only giving the basic premise - the atmosphere is consistently sombre and overarching, and the series is itself amazingly beautiful, with only one scene being visually sub-par by comparison with the rest. Over the course of this volume a number of dynamics also arise, from questions about the humanity of artificial intelligence in the form of Autoreivs, to contrast of dystopian and utopian ideas. Although it has yet to be seen whether there is intellectual value in the series, it also nonetheless generates a number of references to philosophers and other notable thinkers, from Descartes to Michelangelo and Turin.

The only problems I can foresee, despite how promising a first volume this is, which I have already found hints of - are the potential for intellectual superficiality, and of greater concern, the possibility of becoming itself dull, as a consequence of walking the tight-rope of trying to portray a dull society - in which thought and emotion are discouraged.

Ergo Proxy is a series that you can't help but feel - and that is at the same time its greatest strength, and its greatest flaw. As painful as it is onscreen, so it has been for me, and it was a monster to review. I personally recommend that you try the series for yourself, if you like the sound of it, which is a must, but I have, of course, tried to do justice to the series as it currently stands.

Even with this in mind, Ergo Proxy has so far impressed with its weighty atmosphere, superb animation and intriguing fiction. The first episode is the real show-case, with a clearly inflated budget, great action and the first trappings of mystery, but the whole volume shines in its own murky way - with no one episode failing to advance the story or maintain its hold on the viewer.

In Summary


Visceral, uniquely stylised and reflective, austere and powerful, but unproven and painful at times. Potentially the best new sci-fi anime series in a long time, and for a long time to come.

Review Information

Score: 8 out of 10
Review By: Ryan
Date Published: Sun, 28 Oct 2007
5 responses to our review of "Ergo Proxy #1"

1. Comment by Outlawstar

Have to say I agree with everything youve said, I really enjoyed this first volume and cant wait to get the next one.

I cant help but be intruiged by the political undertone and of course the actions of Re-l, although as of now the most interesting charachter is probably Vincent, cant wait to find out more about him.

Havint seen a more highly polished series in a long time.

Posted on Sun, 28 Oct 2007. Outlawstar rated "Ergo Proxy #1": 8 out of 10.

2. Comment by Trumpster

I agree with much of what you said, Vowing to watch it all since I saw the first episode on an MVM release DVD. Unfortunately the rest of the series so far isn't quite as amazing as the first episode but even so it's still head and shoulders above many other new series.

I have seen the second dvd but won't mention any specific details. They are progressing further into the mysteries of the proxies but there's still a way to go, enough to keep you interested for at least another volume (beyond 2). Some dissapointments and a major cliffhanger that I hope isn't what it seems but it's all good stuff to keep you interested.

My rating for the first volume is 10/10 but is probably only 9/10 for the second, but only cause it cannot emulate the pure amazingness of the first episode and the series up to that point. The originality is fading but my love of the style and curiosity about the mysteries of the series pulls me onward.

Posted on Mon, 29 Oct 2007. Trumpster rated "Ergo Proxy #1": 10 out of 10.

3. Comment by Ryan

I completely agree Trumpster. I highlighted the first episode because it was far and away the best of the volume - and having watched volume 2 (the review of which will be up shortly), I can also say that I share your view that it isn't quite as good as volume 1. Ergo Proxy is still well-worth the price of admission though, and I hope to see more good things in future volumes.

Posted on Tue, 30 Oct 2007. Ryan rated "Ergo Proxy #1": 8 out of 10.

4. Comment by Aiden

Ergo Proxy starts off very strong, I agree. Will it hold up to this quality throughout? I won't spoil it for anyone but it is definitely an interesting series. I have no regrets about watching it.

Posted on Wed, 31 Oct 2007. Aiden rated "Ergo Proxy #1": 8 out of 10.

5. Comment by Wildcard

The first volumes given me mixed feelings. I like the serious tone and its all pretty cool. I just hope it's going somewhere good with the plot, it strikes me as the kind of show that gradually builds up to something.

Still, a decent piece of scifi anime with a cool style.

Posted on Wed, 31 Oct 2007. Wildcard rated "Ergo Proxy #1": 7 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of "Ergo Proxy #1"

Editorial Spotlight

Years ago, when I was at school, an openly gay friend let me borrow Gravitation, and it was quite timely, so I'm glad to have the chance to look at it again, to own the English.. Read more (0 comments)
Throughout the multitude of different worlds and dimensions, she is known by many names, such as ‘The Dimension Witch’ or ‘The Far Eastern Witch.’ .. Read more
I read The Anime Almanac 's recent essay with a great interest. Effectively titled "Greg Ayres and the Fight Against Fansubs", it presents an industry-biased perspective on.. Read more (13 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

Ryan on Ergo Proxy #5

I'm glad you agree, I've fallen behind a bit recently but I will review the last volume soon, and from what I've heard the ending is actually more... (Read more)

Ryan on Ergo Proxy #5

I'm glad you agree, I've fallen behind a bit recently but I will review the last volume soon, and from what I've heard the ending is actually more... (Read more)

Trumpster on Ergo Proxy #5

Finally got around to buying the last two volumes and I was even more dissapointed with volume 5, though no longer of the whole series... (though... (Read more)

Sipher on Laputa - Castle In The Sky

Yes, he is the main villian -.- watch the movie. (Read more)

Ryan on Elemental Gelade #2

@Just Passing Through: sorry, corrected. @Kelly: it's the second volume of the first series. As far as I'm aware, there is a second manga series... (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.