Anime Quick Information

Title: Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - Solid State Society
UK publisher: Manga Ent.
Genre: Sci-Fi
Studio: Production I.G
Type: OVA
Director: Kenji Kamiyama
Year: 2006
Running Time: 1hrs 45mins
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 8.20

Ryan's review

Ryan scored this with 7/10. Disagree?

Ghost in the Shell has risen to become a staple of both the science-fiction genre, and of anime in general, enjoying a meteoric rise from cult anonymity to widespread popularity after the onset of its modern revival.

This revival took all of ten years after the first film by Mamoru Oshii (based on the original manga by Masamune Shirow), seeing both a sequel penned by his own hand (Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence), a twenty six episode series by the Ghost in the Shell Committee, and a sequel series in which Oshii exerted a more direct influence (Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex and Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex 2nd gig respectively). The two films and the two television series do not cohabit the same continuity however, despite their common origins, and as such, this latest film, the first by the Ghost in the Shell Committee, is a sequel to the two Stand Alone Complex series, and not the other films. 

The story follows the activities of Public Security Section 9, an elite government  agency specialising in tactical information warfare. Consisting of a small pool of highly specialised experts, drawn from the military, the police, the mafia and other institutions, Public Section 9 effectively protects the public interest by investigating and resolving high-level crimes, whilst also taking assignments from the government. Chief Diasuke Aramaki represents the height of Section 9's hierarchy; overseeing top-level decision making, negotiation with the Prime Minister and the general conduct of Section 9. Beneath him, Major Motoko Kusanagi, protagonist of the main body of Ghost in the Shell fiction and an unprecedented officer, Togusa, a largely unmodified director of field operations, Batou, next in rank to the major - an imposing figure who acted as the protagonist of Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence - and a few other select members form the secret organisation.

The world of Ghost in the Shell is set against the backdrop of rapid cyberisation, that being the onset of advanced technology that enables affluent members of society to be implanted with robotic parts - chiefly, the enhancement of the mind. Cyberisation can vary from minor augmentation, such as that of the mostly human Togusa, who values his humanity above artificial enhancement, to a full prosthetic swap-out, in which the entire body and mind are replaced by cybernetic equivalents. Within the Ghost in the Shell fiction, the latter does not, however, entail becoming a robot, but instead supplants the soul with a ghost, a projection of the accumulated information, and a general spirit, of the individual. Cyberisation has also seen the relentless expansion of the net, to which all people are hooked, but then exposed to the threat of hacking, or in the case of Major Motoko Kusanagi, whose sense of self belongs to the information that forms her ghost - which interacts with and is swallowed by that on the net - the loss of individuality in the vast and infinite sea of information.

From this premise, it is clear that natural philosophical considerations arise, such as questions about the nature of the individual and the effects of technology on our lives, particularly at the impending extreme of posthumanism. Mamoru Oshii chiefly developed these themes and concerns in his films, but the Ghost in the Shell Committee instead emphasised political implications, and it is in this that Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex Solid State Society finds its theme; the socio-political repercussions of falling birth-rates and an ageing population.    

The dialogue throws out an unprecedented amount of information - so much that repeat viewings are almost a necessity to follow basic conversations - which is both characteristic of the series, and often ancillary, rising in crescendo toward small pockets of action, followed by a larger but typically anti-climactic battle that leads to the true unveiling of the threat at hand. This formula is subverted to a degree in the latest film due to the somewhat open-ended nature of the ending, but remains largely intact and more evident than ever, making it perhaps the most predictable of the films thus far. The ending, although perhaps the most unique element of the film, is also perhaps among its least impressive.

Not wanting to ruin the story, I'd rather draw attention to the essence of the film, which is more readily accessible, and certainly more rewarding for the Ghost in the Shell faithful. This is because Solid State Society does not cater for people without at least a minimal understanding of the series fiction, with no attempt to introduce or reintroduce characters, explain terminology unique to the series or elaborate on the world in which the characters reside (other than in an extra on the DVD - that is, the limited edition one, anyway). Beyond this, Solid State Society is more characteristic of the Standalone Complex series than the two films by Mamoru Oshii, and in particular, the original series, for the absence of said director. Unfortunately, it is at this point that Solid State Society becomes overtly stale, prosaic and soulless by comparison with Oshii's more considerate and imaginative predecessors, lacking the atmosphere and magic infused in his productions. The film is not so much wanting for moments of spectacle - such as the establishing scenes, Motoko's jump or the pathos that envelops Togusa when his daughter is being taken from him - and is indeed highly stylised, but rather, it lacks originality. The most common criticism of the film is that it feels like an extended episode of one of the series, and this is true enough, with the animation and narrative barely straying from the conventions of the series.

It is by no means a bad film though, and fans of the series should enjoy the cinematic treatment given to the Ghost in the Shell world. Those particularly adversed to Oshii's philosophical musings and well placed quotes - or, as some would have it, erudition and pomp - may find a slightly more down to earth alternative in the hands of the able Kenji Kamiyama. Watching the film several times also makes the sheer depth of it all painfully obvious, even if it doesn't particularly expand the core themes or ideas found in other Ghost in the Shell releases. It is in this light that I would recommend the film primarily, and, mirroring the tint of disappointment I found with the film, almost exclusively, to established fans of the series.

In Summary

Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex Solid State Society is more of the politically charged same, and though it is characteristic of the modern revival of Ghost in the Shell as a whole, it feels like a good - albeit slightly hollow - bullet point in this great series, rather than the jewel in its crown.

Screenshots (click to pop out)

Review Information

Score: 7 out of 10
Review By: Ryan
Date Published: Fri, 5 Oct 2007
5 responses to our review of "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - Solid State Society"

1. Comment by Trumpster

As a fan of the series more so than the previous movies I found this movie most enjoyable, especially with the extra depth added to some of the characters and providing a vision of the circumstances after Motoko's departure at the end of the second series.

That said I was dissapointed that the quality of the animation was little better than that shown in the series, due to it being a television production in Japan. As much as I like the series and the universe of GITS as a whole, this feels more like a feature length final episode than a well styled movie and makes it fall short of the 10/10 I'd like to give it.

Posted on Sat, 6 Oct 2007. Trumpster rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 8 out of 10.

2. Comment by Wildcard

Thought it was pretty decent really. It's true that the begining is very chatty and that the animation isn't up to the standard that Innocence's was. However, providing you've seen 2nd GIG I think it all goes down pretty well.

Posted on Sat, 6 Oct 2007. Wildcard rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 8 out of 10.

3. Comment by Martin

Ryan's review and the above comments neatly sum up my impressions of the film. It is no more and no less a feature-length SAC episode, which means it's more accessible than Oshii's movies but at the same time lacks the 'epic' feel. Of course, there's no shortage of tense moments (especially those featuring Togusa and his daughter) and some awesome tachikoma action (which is always welcome, right? ^_^).

It's not exactly ground-breaking but is an enjoyable and worthy addition to the franchise - I can still recommend it to fans of the genre.

Posted on Sat, 6 Oct 2007. Martin rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 8 out of 10.

4. Comment by Spike

Hired it out the other day, and enjoyed it a lot. Got round to watching it twice as I usually do if I'm thinking of buying it, y'know to make sure it's as much fun after the first, and it certainly was. Often the fear is with sequel or carry on movies that major characters go missing, well thankfully not this time. They were all there...including Batou and his rather nice looking Ford GT =D

There were a few twists and turns, and as Martin said, plenty of tense scenes which add to it. The finale was really enjoyable and fun.

Overall, I'd say it's well worth it, get out there and hire it out at the very least.

Posted on Wed, 10 Oct 2007. Spike rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 8 out of 10.

5. Comment by Aiden

I really enjoyed it and it certainly is a worthy addition to the GITS:SAC brand.

It looked good, it had an interesting and well managed plot and it at least achieves the quality of the series, handling its characters well throughout the duration.

Certainly not ground breaking but having watched it only expecting to be entertained, it certainly did the business.

Posted on Thu, 11 Oct 2007. Aiden rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 9 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex - Solid State Society"

Editorial Spotlight

 'Parasyte' is a reasonably well realised synthesis of drama, action and philosophy. Hitoshi Iwaaki's story follows the journey of protagonist Shinichi as he deals with the.. Read more
At one time or another in their lives, everyone has probably made the fervent wish, ‘If only I could turn the clock back and do things differently…’ Makoto.. Read more (0 comments)
As the year draws to a close, I've been scanning the lists of anime to be released in the UK on DVD at Christmas with a slightly jaundiced eye. Don't get me wrong.. Read more (0 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

downrater87 on Berserk #4

boooooooooooooooo your gay (Read more)

Dizzae on Eureka Seven #4

They hide in FAC-51, The Hacienda, I lol'd. I love trying to spot all the music references in this show. (Read more)

Trumpster on Buso Renkin #1

From your similarities section I get the feeling that both series are a lot like Shakugan no Shana, but hell I love that series (Much more than... (Read more)

Nate on Big O

Oozes style,depth,mystery and explosive action....,also has a breath-taking soundtrack. I urge anyone to watch this even if they don't like... (Read more)

Sarah on Trinity Blood

I enjoyed 'Trinity Blood' for all the wrong reasons: beautiful bishonen character designs and a wonderfully twisted relationship between Ion and... (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.