Anime Quick Information
| Title: | Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex #1 |
| UK publisher: | Manga Ent. |
| Genre: | Action, Sci-Fi, Thriller |
| Studio: | Production I.G |
| Type: | TV Series |
| Director: | Kenji Kamiyama |
| Year: | 2002 |
| Running Time: | 1hr 40mins |
| Average Rating: 9.20 |
Paul's review
Paul scored this with 9/10. Disagree?
It's almost impossible to exist inside modern anime fandom without feeling the over-bearing influence of Mamoru Oshii's landmark feature 'Ghost in the Shell', a film cited by many as a genuine classic of contemporary science fiction, let alone Japanese animation.
Ghost in the Shell (the movie), while based inside the universe of Masamune Shirow's ever popular manga (of same name), isolated several of the more light hearted elements of the original story and (in true Oshii style) presented a sober, philosophical opinion of our future.
'Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex' is intended to be a much more faithful retelling of Shirow's work; borrowing his sense of humour and emotional tone as well as the labyrinth cyber-punk themes and vivid technology that made the original anime such a firm favourite. As a result, the likes of Major Motoko Kusanagi and Bateau, despite sharing many of the same Japanese voice actors (who have continued their fine work from Oshii's film), come off feeling like completely different characters, each with their own individual sense of humour and personality quirks.
Stand Alone Complex is all about Public Peace: Section 9, an elite group of law enforcers who tackle much of the most important and complicated crimes in a modern world where the line between technology and humanity is becoming increasingly blurred.
Section 9 is run by Aramaki, a dedicated old man with a raw enthusiasm for his job. Major Motoko Kusanagi is his second in command; a preciously talented hacker and 'hard as nails' fighter - she tends to be at the forefront of almost everything Section 9 has planned. Kusanagi's team includes the likes of Bateau (one of Kusanagi's best friends - a rather jolly character with a vested interest in military technology) and Togusa (a thoughtful ex-police officer with a [Chris Waddle] mullet - the only member of Section 9 to not have been especially enhanced with cyborg technology; essentially, he is almost 100% old fashioned human).
This first volume of Stand Alone Complex introduces us to the everyday routines of the Section 9 team as we follow them around on a few of their exciting missions. Along the way we meet a deranged 'Tachikoma' (an advanced tank implanted with artificial intelligence) and get in on a few convoluted government conspiracies, while all the time becoming familiar with the various larger than life personalities that embody Section 9.
It's good that at such an early stage of the series, the writers down at Production I.G have given us a chance to get to grips with the extremely layered world illustrated for us in Ghost in the Shell. The first three episodes are all self-contained, weaving their own little tales while also allowing us to become familiar with much of the modern technologies that dominate this vision of the future.
It's great to see Section 9 in action and doing the typical kind of work that they would consider normal practice - as we see them joking between each other, the viewer develops an attachment and sense of relation to each of these strong individuals. Bateau is obviously a very relaxed figure who, on occasion, enjoys a good bit of physical contact, while Togusa, like many of us, lacks a hint of self confidence and doubts his marksmanship during the heat of conflict. It becomes genuinely fun to see them verbally sparring between each other; exchanging thoughts and philosophies, adding a sense of warmth and emotion to a story that in dominated by the reality of soulless machines.
The action scenes hit us at a break neck speed, pumping us with adrenaline as 'the Major' jumps from roof top to roof top. All of this is powered by (legendary anime soundtrack composer) Yoko Kanno's fantastic score, dragging us head first into Shirow's violent yet beautiful world.
If there is one mixed aspect about Stand Alone Complex, it is that the story can be a little too hard to follow at times. We are often sucked into a myriad of convoluted government conspiracies, and on occasion, the viewer is left desperately trying to keep up with the experts at Section 9 as they delve deeply into their investigations.
Ghost in the Shell has always had a strong sense of confidence in the intelligence of its audience, and it is quickly made apparent to us that the story intends to go deeper than the instant fan-service of Major Kusanagi's tight fitting uniform.
It is disappointing then that such oft-complicated stories are compounded by Manga UK's error-prone DVD release. The most basic of mistakes is a subtitle timing problem that dominates the first episode; with subtitles appearing either too fast or too late, this obviously adds unneeded pressure to an already hard to follow plot-line. Then consider some well known problems with audio quality and all in all, these are the type of basic errors that really take the shine off of what should be a stellar release for the UK. The picture quality is fantastic and the animation looks stunningly fluid, so it is a real shame then that other aspects of this release aren't up to the same high standards.
But I can't end this review on a negative note, and the strange little Tachikoma tanks certainly merit some special attention! Most would expect a talking tank to have a very manly, tobacco chomping voice but funnily enough, the Tachikoma's all sound like wimpy little girls! Not only that, they are very excitable and have an inquizative, almost philosophical nature. Essentially, Tachikomas’ work as amusing little diversions from an otherwise very serious anime series and are so successfully weird that they become one of the most memorable aspects to take away from this outstanding first volume of Stand Alone Complex.
In Summary
Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex #1 lives up to the massive level of expectation set by the original 1995 smash-hit film, and goes on to add personality and humour to a story previously dominated by lifeless technology. Each of the mini-stories are engaging and interesting, the characters feel more human than ever before, the animation from Production I.G is beautiful and Yoko Kanno's musical talent is as strong as ever. If it weren't for the problematic errors on Manga UK's DVD, this would be an almost perfect release.
For fans of science fiction, you won't get much better than Stand Alone Complex.
Screenshots (click to pop out)
Review Information
| Score: | 9 out of 10 |
| Review By: | Paul |
| Date Published: | Tue, 12 Oct 2004 |
|
After being lured into anime fandom through hard-edged science fiction and edge-of-your-seat action-fests I've always wondered how exactly I started to gravitate towards the..
Read more
(1 comments)
|
|
|
Great Artwork, Clear Storytelling, An Involving Cast of Characters…
Del Rey Manga Round-Up Spring 2008
I really love the..
Read more
(1 comments)
|
|
|
Spanking new from Del Rey comes ‘Fairy Tale’, the eagerly anticipated new manga by Hiro Mashima ( www.delreymanga.com ) . Mashima is already known in the west as the..
Read more
|
|
|
The story of Ergo Proxy had always split its attention between the events within the domed city of Romdo, a cold, mechanical dystopia closed off from the world, and the bleak..
Read more
(0 comments)
|
|
1. Comment by Batman
Posted on Wed, 20 Oct 2004. Batman rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 10 out of 10.
2. Comment by lupin The 3rd (niko)
Posted on Sat, 27 Nov 2004. lupin The 3rd (niko) rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 6 out of 10.
3. Comment by alchemist
Posted on Sat, 15 Jan 2005. alchemist rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 1 out of 10.
4. Comment by wired_protocol
Its closer to the manga rather than the film... her chara design is spot on... it was the film that altered things. the series is not related to the story of the movie in any way.
Posted on Tue, 18 Jan 2005. wired_protocol rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 8 out of 10.
5. Comment by Serial King Atma
The characters are believable and genuine, and easy to identify with. Complaints about their differences with the movie are unfounded, as Stand Alone Complex is not based on the realities of that movie, but new realities of its own. While the Tachikomas annoyed me a little I loved Motoko's character immensely. C'est la vie.
The DVDs, though not what I'm reviewing, have to be factored into the equation. Sound quality gets some improvement and the disc, especially the special edition, contains many extras.
The animation is of only the highest quality for a series and proves to us why Production I.G. is considered so talented.
Last but not least is the unforgettable soundtrack. Yoko Kanno is a very, VERY talented musical artist. I don't think much more needs to be said on that subject. The track varies greatly in style and substance, but does it in a seamless fashion that fits well with the scenes and mood.
All told, a great series, one which no anime library is complete without, and a great episode to set the series off.
--Serial King Atma--
Posted on Mon, 21 Feb 2005. Serial King Atma rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 10 out of 10.
6. Comment by Roachy
Posted on Wed, 20 Apr 2005. Roachy rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 9 out of 10.
7. Comment by Hiro Yui
Posted on Tue, 9 Aug 2005. Hiro Yui rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 6 out of 10.
8. Comment by Adam Klone
This is truly a masterpeace I have collected Anime for some time now and this is by far my greatest collection. I highly recommend getting this Anime reasons: Story; Perfect.... Action;Plenty.... Music;Thrilling....
Easily scores 10 a 9 would be a crime
Posted on Sun, 13 Nov 2005. Adam Klone rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 10 out of 10.
9. Comment by Martin
Posted on Mon, 23 Jan 2006. Martin rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 9 out of 10.
10. Comment by Tareq
I like GITS SAC more than the movie
Posted on Sun, 29 Jan 2006. Tareq rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 10 out of 10.
11. Comment by Isabella
I agree with Tareq, SAC is way better than the movie.. you get to know the characters more, the animation is newer (and better) and the music is really good.
Posted on Fri, 15 Feb 2008. Isabella rated "Ghost in the Shell: Stand...": 9 out of 10.
Type the characters you see in the picture above.