Anime Quick Information

Title: Full Metal Alchemist #5
UK publisher: Revelation Films
Genre: Action, Drama, Fantasy
Studio: Bones
Type: TV Series
Director: Seiji Mizushima
Year: 2003
Running Time: 1hr 40mins
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 9.33

Andy's review

Andy scored this with 8/10. Disagree?

After the confrontation with Scar left both Elric brothers in quite a state, Ed and Al return home for some much needed healing, both physical and mental. Of course, it’s not long before they’re back on the trail of the Philosopher’s Stone, given fresh hope and fueled by new clues. But every time they seem to get a step closer to their goal, they only hit another barrier that makes it seem further away than ever.
 
The opening episode of this volume sees the boys head home to the quiet little village they left behind four years ago. This episode is a something of a change of pace, and although the quiet ambience of the village means little in the way of action, the time is instead spent on character development. As the brothers relax and unwind, we learn a little more about their past, and again meet their childhood friend and mechanical whiz Winry.
 
The rest of the volume is pretty much business as usual, which is never a bad thing for this series. There are enough fight sequences to keep action junkies interested, including Scar facing off against Lust and Gluttony, and there are shocking revelations aplenty when it’s discovered what the Philosopher’s Stone’s key ingredient really is. Several new characters are also added to the already large roster, but thanks to the superb character design they all quickly stick in the mind.
 
The overarching story continues to move quickly without feeling rushed, and the pieces of the puzzle are beginning to fall into place. Several of the series’ thematic points are also reinforced; what it means to be human is brought in to question when Ed battles a foe similar to Al, while Al starts to question his own existence. The last episode of this volume certainly tugs some heartstrings and gets you thinking a bit more philosophically.
 
As ever, the presentation is top notch. The animation continues to impress, with vibrant colours and great animation. The music is always appropriate, whether it be a light-hearted comedy moment or a tense dramatic moment. The dubbing is also the usual sterling job, with all the major characters well-acted and voiced appropriately. About the only exception is Winry (voiced by Caitlin Glass - no relation); although her lines are delivered well enough, she sounds a little too old for the role (admittedly a rather common issue with dubbed anime girls). Similarly, Gluttony has lost much of the childlike menace of his Japanese voice, and now sounds rather more generically evil. Irritatingly though, the subtitles suffer from a few minor but simple spelling and grammatical errors. While not exactly showstopping, they can prove fairly distracting if reading the subs too closely. These are only minor gripes, however, and certainly don’t detract from the overall experience.
 
In Summary
 
Fullmetal Alchemist is a series that goes from strength to strength, and this volume only helps ascertain its reputation as one of the best anime series on the market. The mix of adventure, emotion, comedy and more continues to entertain while the story is steadily getting deeper and darker. Although getting only four episodes per DVD may seem like poor value for money, when you consider the quality of the series on offer it suddenly doesn’t seem like such a bad deal. All in all, it’s difficult to find fault with something this enjoyable.

Screenshots (click to pop out)

Review Information

Score: 8 out of 10
Review By: Andy
Date Published: Sat, 25 Mar 2006
4 responses to our review of "Full Metal Alchemist #5"

1. Comment by Mak

It's hard to compare this volume of FMA with the previous four, since we are now 20 or so episodes down the line, and the plot is beginning to take shape.
Perhaps the main reason why I find it hard to compare it with other volumes is the strange change of pace. Though this volume shows so much more emotion and character/plot development, it lacks the action given by its predecessors.
Possibly a volume intent on answering questions; and of course, the mystery of the Philosopher's Stone, it seems to put the action on hold for a while to make room for the advancing storyline.
Because of this, I can't give it any more than 8. It's a little slow in places, and the first episode seems such a lethargic start that you wonder how it will carry on.
But, as with every FMA volume, it gives the wonderful animation, characters, emotions and laughs that it always has. There are definitely better volumes (2/4), but there are definitely worse ones (3). But, if you've come this far in the series, don't even think of giving up on it now.

Posted on Mon, 10 Apr 2006. Mak rated "Full Metal Alchemist #5": 8 out of 10.

2. Comment by Ky^Kiske

Kawai Anime ^_^

Posted on Tue, 18 Apr 2006. Ky^Kiske rated "Full Metal Alchemist #5": 10 out of 10.

3. Comment by ed erich lover

i throught its dvd was amazing as well ed looked great in it .

Posted on Tue, 13 Jun 2006. ed erich lover rated "Full Metal Alchemist #5": 10 out of 10.

4. Comment by jonathan

hola soy fantico de animax un saludo a todos

Posted on Thu, 15 Jun 2006. jonathan rated "Full Metal Alchemist #5": 10 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of "Full Metal Alchemist #5"

Editorial Spotlight

Years ago, when I was at school, an openly gay friend let me borrow Gravitation, and it was quite timely, so I'm glad to have the chance to look at it again, to own the English.. Read more (0 comments)
Throughout the multitude of different worlds and dimensions, she is known by many names, such as ‘The Dimension Witch’ or ‘The Far Eastern Witch.’ .. Read more
I read The Anime Almanac 's recent essay with a great interest. Effectively titled "Greg Ayres and the Fight Against Fansubs", it presents an industry-biased perspective on.. Read more (13 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

Ryan on Ergo Proxy #5

I'm glad you agree, I've fallen behind a bit recently but I will review the last volume soon, and from what I've heard the ending is actually more... (Read more)

Ryan on Ergo Proxy #5

I'm glad you agree, I've fallen behind a bit recently but I will review the last volume soon, and from what I've heard the ending is actually more... (Read more)

Trumpster on Ergo Proxy #5

Finally got around to buying the last two volumes and I was even more dissapointed with volume 5, though no longer of the whole series... (though... (Read more)

Sipher on Laputa - Castle In The Sky

Yes, he is the main villian -.- watch the movie. (Read more)

Ryan on Elemental Gelade #2

@Just Passing Through: sorry, corrected. @Kelly: it's the second volume of the first series. As far as I'm aware, there is a second manga series... (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.