Anime Quick Information

Title: Full Metal Alchemist #4
UK publisher: Revelation Films
Genre: Action, Drama, Fantasy
Studio: Bones
Type: TV Series
Director: Seiji Mizushima
Year: 2003
Running Time: 1hr 40mins
Rate this anime:
Average Rating: 8.66

Paranoia Agent's review

Paranoia Agent scored this with 8/10. Disagree?

Aspiring alchemists Ed and Alphonse Elric are back for a fourth helping of transmuting action focusing on their never-ending quest to find that most elusive of pebbles, The Philosopher’s Stone. Before they can get to the business at hand, however, the Elric siblings have to contend with Scar, an enigmatic Alchemist with a thirst for violence. At the same time they find themselves protecting Marcoh, a fugitive with a troubled past, a past that may be inexplicably linked to their own.

Earlier volumes in the FMA series (while entertaining in their own right) failed to nail the right balance between the uproarious and the heartbreaking, coming off either too inane or just downright depressing. With volume four, however, the series has finally found its feet, forsaking juvenile humour in favour of a serious, focussed narrative. Of course, the odd gag inevitably slips through, but as the series moves into darker territory the humour is gently being phased out allowing the series’ dramatic chops to really shine.

Chief among this volume’s highlights is the reappearance of Scar, a scarred (believe it or not) zealot with a very, very big chip on his shoulder. Whenever he’s around something spectacularly gruesome is never far behind and his little tête-à-tête with the kiss curled, Strong Arm Alchemist is one of the best sequences to grace this disc. Up until now he has remained something of an unknown factor, cropping up now and again to put the wind up our young heroes. This volume, however, sheds some light on his bloody quest, and as the pieces of his murky past fall into place it’s clear there’s more to him than your average ‘freak of the week’.

Characterisation is as strong as ever and while the personalities thrown up don’t often err on the side of originality they each have enough ticks and quirks to save them from obscurity. The lengthy stretches of development that pepper the action don’t hurt either and this disc blesses the viewer with plenty of exposition that goes a long way to deepening our understanding of the weird and wonderful world the Brothers Elric inhabit and the people they meet.

Visually, this volume is easily on a par with earlier instalments in the series and the usual combination of graceful line work and silky animation never fails to get the eyes watering. My favourite aspect of the visuals has to be the character designs that have a wonderful, chunky feel reminiscent of cult Dreamcast scrapper, Powerstone. It makes a refreshing change from the angular, dare I say clinical, character design that plagues so many modern anime titles, and while I wouldn’t necessarily slap it with the retro tag it has that mid-nineties flavour.  

In Summary

16 episodes in, and Fullmetal Alchemist shows no signs of slowing down. In fact, I’d go as far to say this disc has been the most impressive yet, blurring the line between the humorous and the heartfelt with a deftness oddly lacking in volumes 1-3. It’s still early days, but if you’re looking for an action adventure with a bit more grit than your average Shounen series you could do a lot worse than give Fullmetal Alchemist a look.

Screenshots (click to pop out)

Review Information

Score: 8 out of 10
Review By: Paranoia Agent
Date Published: Wed, 18 Jan 2006
4 responses to our review of "Full Metal Alchemist #4"

1. Comment by FMAsgal

ED ROOOOOCKZ!!! WOOOO!

Posted on Thu, 19 Jan 2006. FMAsgal rated "Full Metal Alchemist #4": 10 out of 10.

2. Comment by White_Alchemist

FYI Scar's arm doesn't have a chip, its a transmutation circle from his Big Bro.

Funimation has done its usual good work and made a high quality set of FMA.

Posted on Mon, 30 Jan 2006. White_Alchemist rated "Full Metal Alchemist #4": 9 out of 10.

3. Comment by Mak

This volume is a big turning point for FMA in its story and in the anime itself. Up until now, the anime has been impressive, verging on phenomenal. This volume, aptly titled 'The Fall of Ishbal' delves into Scar's past and uncovers the secrets of the Ishbal Massacre, but that's a many as spoilers are you're gonna get from me.

This volume, despite the hype, was not as good as Volume 2. It lacked the psychological horror, angst, suspense and fun that Vol.2 gave to it. But, in a way, that helped. It gave way to an extremely darker anime and opened an extremely complex storyline. Everything that I said it lacked, it didn't forget, it just didn't have the elements as much as Vol.2 did.

This anime is beginning to reach its turning point and I give it a thumbs up. FMA really is a pioneering anime; mainly because it has managed to reinvent the action/fantasy/sci-fi genre as its own, adding a dash of alchemy for inventiveness. Buy this DVD, but don't expect it to be the greatest thing you ever did see, expect it to be one of the top 5 greatest things you ever did see.

Posted on Sun, 12 Feb 2006. Mak rated "Full Metal Alchemist #4": 1 out of 10.

4. Comment by FMAzgal

WOO ED ROOKZ SOOO MUCH! WOOO Hey, did I do the first comment??

Posted on Mon, 27 Feb 2006. FMAzgal rated "Full Metal Alchemist #4": 10 out of 10.

Post your response to our review of "Full Metal Alchemist #4"

Editorial Spotlight

"Music is powerless to express anything." – Igor Stravinsky. Liverpool gave us the Fab Four called "The Beatles", Rutland gave us the Pre-Fab Four.. Read more (0 comments)
"I love those decadent wenches who do so trouble my dreams." – Rembrandt. There are plenty of fan-service filled anime out there, most of which vary in.. Read more (0 comments)
Marika Kato, the sixteen-year-old schoolgirl captain of the pirate spaceship Bentenmaru, has a duty to keep her ship's precious Letter of Marque valid by regularly performing a.. Read more (0 comments)

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Recent Comments

jimmy on Inferno Cop

Annoyed your rating meter levels off at "10", but I enjoyed the review itself. I think the strongest testament to its quality is how the... (Read more)

speedy z5 on Elemental Gelade #2

you there my last post is kinda old and you tend to respond kinda of quickly (Read more)

dylan on Code Geass - Lelouch of the Rebellion R2

code geass season 2 was unbelivable definite 10 (Read more)

adam on Code Geass - Lelouch of the Rebellion R1

coded geass is the best this review should have given it a 10 (Read more)

dylan on Code Geass - Lelouch of the Rebellion R1

code geass is class best series ever it deserves 10 nothing less! (Read more)

About Anime UK News

Anime UK News has been going since 2004, want to contact us or learn a little more about the site? Head to the about us page.