Anime UK News :: Review of Claymore #2

Manga Quick Information

Title:	Claymore #2
Original vintage:	2001
Mangaka:	Norihiro Yagi
Published by:	Viz Media USA
Genre:	Action, Horror, Supernatural, Thriller
Material length:	208 pages

Ben's review

Ben scored this with 5/10.

Following on from the death of Elena and Raki becoming Claire’s cook they both travel to Rabona which is a holy city where there is a huge religious community. A Yoma is present here however holy and Claire, who herself is part Yoma and therefore unholy, must work undercover to expose and destroy the Yoma.

Norihiro Yagi’s trump card here, to differentiate the plot from the same basic formula as volume one, is to disable Claire’s abilities to sense the Yoma facilitating a need to find the Yoma “the Old fashioned way”, i.e. by searching.

In this sense Yagi creates a reasonably good foundation for chronicling the first five dark scenes of “Darkness in Paradise”. His ability to create a dark and repressive atmosphere is brilliant through both his fantastic imagery but also through forging characters that actually care about the city and would readily die for its survival.

The story itself is still far too centred around Claire, that is natural though she is the protagonist, however the fact that Yagi is able to add a dash of characterisation to characters that really care about the city is building upon the shaky foundation Yagi left after the first volume. However does the reader really care about the Rabona or its inhabitants? No, not really. There is merely a dash of characterisation that Yagi adds to characters, actually I did not care whether the two knights who helped Claire in the closing pages of part of five remained alive or died.

Even Claire’s development feels constricted because Yagi is challenging Claire to be what she is not: fully human. She has to go undercover and fails miserably, she still has to use her senses to detect the Yoma’s aura rather than performing the “old fashioned way” of trying to detect the Yoma.

This volume is average and Yagi is trying to prove to us he can diversify however he is slave to his basic formula of Claire arrives, Claire finds Yoma, Claire defeats Yoma, Claire leaves and in spite of the fact that the “Darkness in Paradise” Arc is not yet finished there is a slowness and an average feel to the arc. Yagi is not exploiting what made the first volume a reasonably good read; that synthesis of Claire’s character and past being unpeeled and set against a fantastically dark atmosphere where the story is not so long and drawn out.

So in conclusion volume two of ‘Claymore’ is mediocre and slow, the characters are still uninteresting and paradise really is not paradise. Volume two is a reasonable read, but nothing to write home about. Yagi needs to take his creation back to scene four and the emotional trials and tribulations of being a claymore, for example longing to be human or trying to restrain the Yoma within, not the constant low octane fights being graced in volume two.

Review Information

Score:	5 out of 10
Review By:	Ben
Date Published:	Mon, 30 Jun 2008

Editorial Spotlight

Review of Death Note #12
	'Death Note' enters its twelfth, and final, volume as if it were a chess game nearing its own conclusion with everything in the balance. This volume pits the two geniuses.. Read more
Review of Death Note #11
	‘Death Note’ enters its eleventh, and penultimate, volume of the chess like game being played out between Light and Near. In the world of ‘Death Note’.. Read more
Review of Witchblade #3
	In the last volume reporter-hopeful Tozawa discovered Masane's secret, and forced her into a partnership, aiding his research into the X-con and Cloneblade (Neogene) murders.. Read more (0 comments)

Latest Reviews

Witchblade #3 (0)

Ergo Proxy #6 (3)

School Rumble #2 (0)

Lupin III: The Secret of Mamo (0)

Berserk #3 (0)

Manga Reviews

Yotsuba&! - Volumes 1 - 5

xxxHolic - Volumes #7 and #8

[View ALL manga reviews]

Nakama Britannica

Nakama Britannica is a blog aggregator populated by the Anime UK News communty.

Condensed Review: StrikerS by IKnight

Cadbury’s Dairy Milk Aprico.. by Doberman Pharaoh

Natsume Yuujinchou 3-6: when .. by Martin

View all posts at Nakama Britannica

Latest Updates

Thursday, 4 September

Death Note #12

[News Archive]

Got news?

Got some news? E-mail it to news@AUKN

Upcoming UK Releases

[View Full Schedule]
Mon, 8 Sep 2008
Brave Story	Optimum Asia
Coyote Ragtime Box Set	ADV Films
E's Otherwise Box Set	ADV Films
Gravitation #3	MVM Films
Pumpkin Scissors #3	ADV Films
Shana #3	MVM Films
Tsukihime Lunar Legend Box Set	MVM Films
Mon, 15 Sep 2008
Black Lagoon: Second Barrage #1	MVM Films
Ghost in The Shell SAC Trilogy Box Set	Manga Ent.
Mar #2	Manga Ent.